Disney’s live action take on the classic Dumbo soared across screens nationwide on March 29th, and I’m answering some big questions on how appropriate the film is for children who are in foster care or adopted.
As a kid I watched the animated version of Dumbo over and over. I loved it, as I did just about every Disney movie back then. Even as a youngster, I stood up and cheered when Dumbo finally silenced his critics and took a leap off of that platform, spread his ears wide, and soared over the crowd. What a triumph! What a silencer of the haters! For this insecure, awkward, often picked-on little boy, Dumbo was my hero.
So of course, my heart leapt a bit last year when I heard that my classic favorite was being turned into a live-action movie. A few days ago my oldest son and I grabbed our tickets, and popcorn, and found our seats to take in this new release. I had to spend some time explaining that this was a live-action remake of one of Disney’s most classic movies in history. He thought it was a brand new movie. Ahh, kids these days!
I have to tell you. Dumbo did not disappoint from an adult perspective. A storyline that did not drag out, or become confusing, contain unnecessary plot points, or lose the audience kept this easily distracted moviegoer engaged. That’s Disney’s thumbprint with movies anymore. No wonder they sell theaters out worldwide! Lead actors and actresses Eva Green, Colin Farrell, Danny DeVito, and Michael Keaton, were believable and authentic, not to mention Nico Parker and Finley Hobbins who plaid Holt Farrier’s (Farrell) children in the film. Cute as can be!
But the question I want to answer in this review is whether or not Dumbo is appropriate to take children too. Particularly children you are caring for who have struggled with the loss of their biological family, still grieving, or have come from significant trauma. We talk a lot on this blog about strategies to help you navigate trauma history (sometimes severe) with your children, so I want to give you a first hand perspective from a parent who is right in the middle of doing just that.
Aspects Of The Movie To Be Cautious Of (Spoilers)
I did take my 15 year old son to see the movie and he liked it. He was witness to domestic violence as a toddler, and has also spent a lot of time in residential treatment over the years for behavioral issues so I went into this movie with him cautiously. I expected that we would be processing some of the hard storyline together as we drove home. If you are unfamiliar with Dumbo, the remake follows the storyline of Dumbo and his mother, Mrs. Jumbo being separated from one another due to her aggression that causes destruction at the circus early on in the film. However, my son wasn’t phased.
He may be the exception, not the rule. So, is Dumbo appropriate for children who have been adopted, or are currently in foster care?
I don’t think so.
After watching this film, and trying to view the story through the lens of a child who is grieving the loss of their first family, or just wrestling with feelings of grief or loss in general, I don’t think it’s a good idea to take them to see this film. Here’s why…
- The theme of loss and separation is HEAVY throughout the film. The movie begins with Holt returning from war and reuniting with his children. His wife passed away while he was gone, leaving the children with care takers until he returned. From there, we witness Dumbo’s separation from his mother, and finally Dumbo and his mother leaving New York on a ship for the jungle. It’s celebratory because they are finally together, but sad because Dumbo is now leaving.
- Dumbo’s mother is sold off after she loses her temper after trying to protect Dumbo. Depending on the circumstances surrounding the removal of your child from their biological parent’s home, viewing this could be a trigger.
- When Dreamland falls apart, and Holt and his children are trapped in a burning tent toward the end, it’s intense. There was a mother sitting next to us with her young daughter (probably 3 or 4) and she burst into tears when Dreamland was collapsing and the family was trapped. She jumped in her mother’s lap while hiding her face and screamed “Make it stop mommy!” It’s too much for young children, and too much for children who have experienced significant trauma.
I really did love this film. While I don’t believe children who have experienced loss, or have a significant trauma history should see Dumbo, it really was well done, and will be a classic for decades to come (just like it’s predecessor, the animated Dumbo from 1941).
Hopefully this review helps you make a healthy informed decision for your family.
Question: Did you see the film? What was your take on it? Share with us in the comment section below this post. You can leave a comment by clicking here.
Get our latest eBook for FREE!
Let’s be honest: parenting is exhausting. You feel worn out, foggy & can’t remember the last time you got a full night’s sleep. That’s why we’ve put together a FREE guide with easy-to-apply, rest multiplying hacks for busy parents. You’re just 9 days away from feeling rested, refreshed & reenergized!